Who in National refused to donate?
May 2, 2008I see DPF had a go at working out who in Labour refused to donate to the party. He got this information from the Electoral Commission’s recently published list of donations made to political parties over $10,000. It’s all great detective work by DPF. I wondered whether the same kind of robust and difficult analysis could be applied to the National Party. It was exceedingly difficult (drawing on public information and all), but here’s my analysis of which of the 48 National Party MPs did not donate to their political party during 2007 calendar year (with the same caveat that Davey used that some of these MPs might have donated less than $10,000 disclosure threshold):
- Ardern, Shane
- Auchinvole, Chris
- Bennett, David
- Bennett, Paula
- Blue, Jackie
- Blumsky, Mark
- Borrows, Chester
- Brownlee, Gerry
- Carter, David
- Carter, John
- Clarkson, Bob
- Coleman, Jonathan
- Collins, Judith
- Connell, Brian
- Dean, Jacqui
- English, Bill
- Finlayson, Christopher
- Foss, Craig
- Goodhew, Jo
- Goudie, Sandra
- Groser, Tim
- Guy, Nathan
- Hayes, John
- Heatley, Philip
- Henare, Tau
- Hutchison, Paul
- Key, John
- King, Colin
- Mapp, Wayne
- McCully, Murray
- Peachey, Allan
- Power, Simon
- Rich, Katherine
- Roy, Eric
- Ryall, Tony
- Shanks, Katrina
- Simich, Clem
- Smith, Lockwood
- Smith, Nick
- te Heuheu, Georgina Manunui
- Tisch, Lindsay
- Tolley, Anne
- Tremain, Chris
- Wagner, Nicky
- Wilkinson, Kate
- Williamson, Maurice
- Wong, Pansy
- Worth, Richard
So, 48 out of 48 of National’s MPs REFUSED (to use Davey’s words) to donate more than $10,000 to their party - unlike, as DPF helpfully points out, most of the MPs in the Labour Caucus. So, DPF’s point was what exactly?
It’s just dawned on me that another explanation is that some or many of National’s MPs - particularly millionaires like Mr Key - might have donated to the Party through one of the hidden Trusts that National uses to mask its secret backers. Of course, we the public of New Zealand wouldn’t know because these Trust donors have been cloaked in secrecy.
[Zoster adds: It should be noted the Green Party MPs routinely undertake this kind of tithing - much to their collective credit]